In the days that followed the bombings in Bali, the island
was a buzz of activity. Rumors were flying about who was
behind the violence and whether it could be linked to militant
Muslim networks like Al-Qaeda and Jamaah Islamiyah. Police and
military kept watch over Bali's borders and started the hunt
for the perpetrators. Civilian patrols scoured villages,
checking immigrants' identity cards and registering
'outsiders' in the name of security. Even before an
international team of volunteers had finished tending to the
wounded, Indonesia's politicians and public relations people
were already hard at work staking their positions and
attempting to salvage the country's image. And from all around
the world, journalists started arriving in Bali, which had
suddenly migrated from the travel pages to the headlines.
The international media that covered the bombings
invariably mentioned that Bali is 'Indonesia's only Hindu
island.' Most of these reports described Bali as a legendary
oasis of peace and harmony, home to an ancient civilization
that now seemed to be under threat from its Muslim neighbors,
who make up the majority of Indonesia's population. Few noted
the violence that had marked Bali's history-from the
pre-colonial conflicts between rival kingdoms to the armed
resistance against the Dutch to the state-sponsored terror of
1965, in which some 100,000 Balinese were massacred in the
space of a few months, to the Indonesian occupation of East
Timor, which used Bali as its military logistics base. Nor did
many reporters note that what had come under attack in Kuta
was not the mythical traditional Bali portrayed in tourist
guidebooks, but a modern, multicultural hub inhabited by
people from all around the world. And even fewer acknowledged
that while the majority of Bali's population is indeed Hindu,
the island has long been home to Buddhists, Christians and
Muslims as well.
This last omission was perhaps not surprising. Little ink
has been spilled, either in academic journals or tourism
industry promotions, about Bali's ethnic and religious
diversity. While tourism in Bali depended on a steady influx
of labor from neighboring islands, postcards of Bali's fabled
charms featured the pageantry of Hindu religious rituals and
images from Hindu myth and legend. Tour buses brought visitors
to don sarongs and ceremonial sashes and traipse through
temples-not to listen to the Christian liturgy or to watch
Muslims praying in mosques. Hinduism-colorful, complex,
mystical-became an image that could be marketed to tourists in
search of exotic difference, attracting a very different kind
of attention than Christianity-perceived in the West as
familiar and fundamentally universal-or Islam-seen as alien
and vaguely threatening.
But behind the glossy packaged
pictures of a harmonious, homogenous Bali, what are
inter-ethnic relations really like? And as tourists avoid Bali
out of fear of violence, the island's economy suffers, and
blame is assigned to a few extremist Indonesian Muslims, will
conflict between Bali's Hindus and Muslims erupt, as some have
feared?
'I am Balinese, I am Muslim'
Nyoman Muhammad Alim (22)
and Wayan Sudirta (21) have been friends since childhood.
Every day, they would play, bathe in the river and look after
their cattle together. 'He was like my brother, we went
everywhere together. He often slept over at my house,'
remembers Wayan Sudirta. The two boys remained close even
after they were sent to different schools. Alim studied at
local Islamic primary and junior high schools, while Sudirta
went to government-sponsored schools. It was only when it came
time for high school that the two friends were separated.
Sudirta went to Denpasar to live with a relative and attend a
public high school, while Alim went to live with his uncle in
Banyuwangi, East Java, and attend an Islamic boarding school
(pesantren).